Comey advisor Richman was told he was a DOJ target, then told he wasn't, then he pleaded the Fifth
Securing the Columbia Law School professor and Comey pal Daniel Richman’s testimony has been chaotic. His lawyers say prosecutors in the "grand conspiracy" probe changed his target status three times, sent an immunity letter the afternoon before he testified, and threatened his building staff with obstruction over serving a subpoena.
A top advisor to former FBI Director James Comey says in legal filings that he was informed he was a target, then that he was not a target, then offered immunity, and then pleaded his Fifth Amendment rights. It appears to have been a chaotic several months for the grand jury process and probes into Comey, the newly filed court documents show.
The new details were disclosed in a court filing by lawyers for Daniel Richman, a law professor who was at one time an advisor to then-FBI Director Comey. Richman’s lawyers submitted the Nov. 13 filing in federal court in Washington, D.C., where CNN is asking U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly to unseal Justice Department records from Richman’s earlier court fight to recover electronic files the government seized from him.
Richman was at the center of the first federal case targeting Comey, who was indicted by a grand jury for allegedly lying to Congress in 2020 when he denied authorizing anyone at the FBI to be an anonymous source in news reports.
It turned out that Comey authorized his friend and special FBI employee, Richman, to communicate with a New York Times reporter “to correct stories critical of Comey, the FBI and to shape future press coverage,” Just the News previously reported, citing government memos.
Prosecutors later filed emails showing Comey urging Richman in November 2016 about a Times reporter’s coverage of the Clinton email probe. “Perhaps you can make him smarter,” Comey wrote, according to the Justice Department filing.
Comey indicted three times, first matter dismissed
That case was dismissed in November 2025 after a judge found that the prosecutor who secured it, Lindsey Halligan, had been unlawfully appointed. Comey was indicted again in April in North Carolina over his “86 47” seashell post; that case is set for trial in February 2027. Comey was charged a third time in October 2026 with alleged disclosure of national defense information and a conspiracy to do so.
The new court filing shows how prosecutors in South Florida are continuing to try to secure testimony from Richman more than a year after the first case charging Comey with lying to Congress was dismissed.
You can read the new filing below:
Richman was “definitely a target,” court filings say
Two months ago, prosecutors in Florida issued a subpoena for Richman’s testimony, indicating that the Justice Department had opened a new front of its investigation of Comey for allegedly leaking classified information, Just the News reported.
In September, Richman’s attorney spoke with Joseph diGenova, then Counselor to the Attorney General and in charge of the Justice Department’s so-called “grand conspiracy” investigation in South Florida. According to the court filings, diGenova told the lawyer that Richman was “definitely a target.”
Richman’s lawyer asked why he had not received a target letter, as DOJ policy requires. DiGenova answered that his “team is in the process of getting onboarded, and we’re discussing things like that,” the lawyers wrote. DiGenova then added: “In my mind, [Professor Richman] is definitely a target, but not in the grand jury’s mind; in their mind, he’s a subject.”
In the same conversation, diGenova also promised that Richman would get a letter granting immunity before he testified. "letter immunity" is a legal term of art consisting of a private agreement between a witness and prosecutors that is narrower than statutory immunity. That letter was supposed to be delivered in advance of Richman’s testimony.
However, the confusion began almost immediately. The following day, per Richman’s lawyers, the second prosecutor on diGenova’s team told Richman’s lawyers that Richman was “obviously” a subject, but, that some of Richman’s conduct “could be in the realm of criminality.”
Richman was informed the day before his grand jury appearance by a third prosecutor that Richman was “originally a target” but was not any longer. There was also confusion over an effort to secure letter–or informal–immunity for Richman before his scheduled testimony on September 10 in order to determine whether his client should seek full statutory immunity instead.
Despite promises from prosecutors that the immunity would be delivered promptly, prosecutors only sent the letter at 3:37 p.m. on the day before Richman’s 10:00 a.m. testimony. Less than two hours later, Richman’s lawyers told the government he would invoke his right against self-incrimination unless he was given statutory immunity.
Prosecutors had said they would try to get it, but the team “ultimately did not receive DOJ approval to move for statutory immunity,” the lawyers wrote. On Sept. 10, Richman appeared as ordered and, according to his lawyers, “after waiting for hours, exercised his Fifth Amendment privilege.” His lawyers added that “His appearance was a waste of time and taxpayer dollars.”
DiGenova resigned from his post at the Justice Department on the same day, “apparently while Mr. Richman was sitting outside the grand jury room,” Richman’s lawyers wrote.
Even serving Richman with the subpoena turned into a standoff, according to the filing.
On Aug. 28, a Miami-based FBI agent confirmed in writing that Richman’s lawyer had agreed to accept it on his behalf: “Thank you so much for returning my call and accepting service of the subpoena on behalf of Mr. Richman.” Yet, less than an hour later, the same agent called back seeking to personally serve the papers on Richman.
Accepting service through counsel was “not good enough,” diGenova says
On Sunday, Aug. 30, while Richman was out of town, FBI agents went to his New York apartment building and told staff they had “instructions to deliver something to someone” in his apartment. When the staff refused to let them upstairs, one agent said they were “under instructions that if people don’t let us up, they’re going to be charged with obstruction,” the lawyers wrote.
DiGenova later told Richman’s lawyer that accepting service through counsel was “not good enough” and claimed that “[t]he grand jury requested that we serve [Professor Richman] personally.” A prosecutor then said the service attempt was among the issues the grand jury was investigating. When Richman arrived in Fort Pierce on Sept. 10, two employees of his building were in the grand jury waiting room under subpoenas of their own. Richman’s lawyers called any obstruction charge against him “patently and facially meritless.”
Leaks to the press have been at the center of federal prosecutors’ efforts to charge ex-FBI Director Comey, but several prior probes have fallen short.
Just the News previously reported on declassified FBI memos detailing “Tropic Vortex,” a classified-leak investigation that then-U.S. Attorney John Durham and the U.S. Postal Inspection Service opened in March 2017. The D.C. U.S. Attorney’s Office later took it over and declined to prosecute in January 2020.
Comey’s indictment in September 2025, also centered on media leaks. It charged that he lied to Congress in 2020 when he denied authorizing anyone at the FBI to be an anonymous source in news reports. At the same time, Richman admitted to agents in a separate leak probe, code-named “Arctic Haze,” that he communicated with New York Times reporter Michael Schmidt “to correct stories critical of Comey, the FBI and to shape future press coverage,” according to FBI memos Just the News first reported.