Coalition of NYC business groups threaten lawsuit over Mamdani-backed 'delivery protection' bill
A coalition of business groups is threatening to sue if the New York City Council approves legislation that would require Amazon and other large online retailers to directly hire delivery workers. Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced his support for the changes.
(The Center Square) -
(The Center Square) — A coalition of business groups is threatening to sue if the New York City Council approves legislation that would require Amazon and other large online retailers to directly hire delivery workers.
In a letter to Council Speaker Julie Menin that was viewed online by The Center Square, a civil rights attorney hired by the Five Borough Jobs Campaign and the New York Delivers Coalition said an analysis of the proposed "delivery protection" bill, called Intro 518, suggests that it "directly conflicts with existing federal and state law and raises serious legal questions about the city’s authority to enact it."
"The legislation provides no compensation or meaningful recourse to the businesses it would eliminate," attorney Derek Sells, of the Cochran Firm, wrote to Menin and other lawmakers. "If the City takes action that unlawfully and painfully destroys these businesses, those owners may have legal grounds to pursue recovery for the resulting losses."
Sells urged council members to reject the proposal when it comes to a vote or strike the direct-employment mandate, the subcontracting prohibition and the rehiring provisions in the proposed legislation. Nothing short of that would stop a potential lawsuit, he said.
"The city should not assume it can eliminate an entire industry of locally owned businesses without facing the financial and legal consequences of doing so," Sells added.
Menin was not immediately available for comment to The Center Square on Tuesday.
In a prior statement made available to The Center Square, Menin said, “It’s time for Amazon to adhere to a licensing framework that ensures fair pay, strong worker protections, and more responsible delivery practices that don’t leave vehicles idling on our streets for hours.”
The attorney said Intro 518 could also affect drivers and businesses operating outside New York City's five boroughs, including facilities in New Jersey, Westchester, New York, and Long Island, New York.
"This raises additional legal questions about the city's authority to regulate businesses beyond its borders and its impact on interstate commerce," Sells said.
The proposal, filed by Councilwoman Tiffany Cabán, a Queens Democrat, would require operators of "last-mile" warehouses and storage facilities to get licenses from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection and meet new safety, training, and employment requirements, among other changes.
If approved, the measure would ban major logistics and delivery companies — including Amazon and FedEx — from using third-party contractors or delivery service providers for last-mile deliveries and key warehouse operations across the city’s five boroughs.
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced his support for the changes in August, saying it would "rein in the power of corporate delivery giants like Amazon, hold them accountable for their exploitative business model and make New York City’s streets safer for workers, drivers and pedestrians."
The Center Square was unable to reach the mayor’s office for an updated position at the time of publication.
The letter to council members this week is the latest pushback from business groups who have vowed to defeat the proposal, which they say will cost jobs and hurt the Big Apple's economy.
Amazon, which says it relies on more than 40 third-party delivery companies in New York City that employ more than 5,000 people, has also said those jobs would be at risk if the legislation is approved. The company says it has been working with city council members on alternative proposals.