Free speech groups gang up on deep-blue states to block AI censorship, government mouthpiece laws

Social media trade group sues New York to stop tobacco-style warning labels that users can't click through, similar to Colorado's blocked law. ACLU joins libertarians against Minnesota AI "nudification" law that goes way past nudity.

Published: November 18, 2026 10:48pm

A common campaign theme among victorious Democrats in this month's agenda-setting midterms was stiffer regulation of social media and artificial intelligence, seeking to build on the momentum of Meta's massive settlements with dozens of states and New Mexico separately for data collection and design choices pertaining to children.

But cross-ideological legal challenges to deep-blue states' laws, and their mixed record of defending similar laws in court, cast doubt on how much the victors can deliver without wasting taxpayer dollars on fruitless legal defenses.

Tech industry trade group NetChoice, representing social media companies including Meta and X, sued New York to block its new law that would slap recurring tobacco-style warnings on "addictive" features in Empire State users' feeds with escalating duration and frequency, portraying them as annoying pop-ups as well as unconstitutional compelled speech.

The warnings, which would initially cover a quarter of the page for 10 seconds, then three-quarters and 30 seconds after the first three hours and subsequently every hour, would apply to everyone the platform has not "reasonably determined" is older than 17. 

NetChoice litigation blocked a similar Colorado law this month and targeted California's "censorship labels" last month, deeming them "even more extreme" than Colorado's.

Such warnings resemble the state-prescribed disclaimers that obscure AI-generated political satire and ruin the joke. First Amendment litigation quickly invalidated them in Hawaii and California and is ongoing against a similar New Mexico law.

But New York's "hateful conduct" reporting law, blocked by a federal judge in 2023, got a second chance this summer when a split state appeals panel – tasked by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals with interpreting its terms – found it likely constitutional. In the interim, plaintiffs accused state Democratic Attorney General Letitia James of illegally jawboning social media.

Several First Amendment groups are supporting Elon Musk's AI company – recently renamed SpaceX Super Intelligence but still listed in their legal briefs as SpaceXAI – against Minnesota's so-called AI nudification ban, which the 8th Circuit blocked pending appeal without explanation last month after a district judge refused to block it.

On the political left, they include the ACLU and its Minnesota affiliate as well as the Woodhull Freedom Foundation, which defends "sexual freedom" as a human right. NetChoice also filed a brief.

One of the right-leaning antagonists of the law, the Liberty Justice Center, claims it's written so broadly it could punish platforms when users depict themselves in swimwear, such as President Trump's AI-generated topless image of himself, Vice President JD Vance and male Cabinet members in the Reflecting Pool.

In its review of outside briefs last week, the AI for Lawyers newsletter pointed to a little-noticed exemption that hurts the challengers' case but is the "real flaw" of the law. It exempts tools that still require "the technical skill of a user to nudify an image or video," which lawyer Amy Swaner called "Minnesota's attempt to draw the line between tool and user."

Unlike California and Hawaii, Minnesota escaped legal consequences for its ban on election deepfakes when the full 8th Circuit declined to review a three-judge panel's refusal to block Minnesota's law, finding it had an unwritten parody exception. State Democratic Attorney General Keith Ellison notably got caught submitting an expert declaration with AI "hallucinations."

Bans AI for 'movie production,' bodily depictions 'not ordinarily' considered 'intimate'

NetChoice's litigation, filed Friday, emphasizes New York's mandated warning – that "excessive use may be associated with significant mental health harms" – exceeds a cigarette package warning because it "block[s] access to the underlying speech" and forces users to "wait through the State’s message before they can return to the expression they seek." 

It said the law has the same First and Fourteenth amendments problems as Colorado's, which a federal judge blocked as likely unconstitutional two weeks ago. 

"The Court is hard-pressed to conclude" the content subject to the warning is just "commercial speech," as Colorado argued, according to the Nov. 5 ruling. "Politicians have learned that 'public health' can be used to justify all kinds of overreach, including as a backdoor means for the government to control online speech," NetChoice said after the ruling.

Everything about New York's law targets the content of speech, from its application to services that are primarily "socially interactive" and provide "user-generated content" as opposed to those that publicize only their own editorial content, the suit says. That means the government's policy must be the least restrictive to accomplish its objective.

Even under the lower judicial standard of "intermediate scrutiny," the law cannot survive because it doesn't "directly and materially advanc[e] the asserted governmental interest" and is "more extensive than necessary to serve the interests that support it," NetChoice said.

Minnesota's AI nudification ban complements an "intimate imagery" distribution ban that, unlike the AI law, punishes users for intentionally sharing non-consensual nudes – limitations that were crucial to its constitutionality as determined by the state supreme court.

"There is no denying the significant psychological, safety, and reputational harms caused by" non-consensual intimate imagery, "both real and AI-generated, and those concerns very likely give rise to a compelling governmental interest," but the law is completely missing "crucial safeguards," says the ACLU brief Friday supporting SpaceXSI.

It's so broad it would prohibit "satirical depictions of politicians," consensual AI images "made as part of a movie production" and bodily depictions "not ordinarily considered 'intimate,'" the brief says. The law can't stand without "safeguards regarding an applicable mental state, a concrete definition of the proscribed imagery, matters of public interest, and lack of consent."

The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, First Amendment Lawyers Association and sexual-freedom group Woodhull told the 8th Circuit in a joint brief that the law improperly covers First Amendment-protected "nonsexual nudity and parodic or satirical images" and would chill speech beyond the Land of 10,000 Lakes.

Parodies of public officials "often rely on imitation, exaggeration, and fictional depictions," they said, pointing to the Supreme Court's prohibition on the late Rev. Jerry Falwell seeking damages against Hustler magazine for its parody ad implying he had relations with his mother, which "no reasonable person would understand as asserting actual facts."

But the brief reserves particular ire for U.S. District Judge Donovan Frank's refusal to block the law solely because of the President Clinton nominee's perception that SpaceXSI waited too long to sue, three months.

That's "especially egregious" given that Frank, who hears only a fraction of the normal caseload as a senior judge, admitted constitutional objections to the law deserve "full consideration," they said. The law is "unconstitutionally halting fully protected speech now," which the Supreme Court has said "unquestionably" constitutes irreparable injury, the brief says. 

The Liberty Justice Center's brief supporting SpaceXSI, its third in the litigation, slams Judge Frank for "categorically misstating" an 8th Circuit precedent so that it "contradicts ironclad precedent on how courts must assess the public interest" when considering whether to block a law as litigation proceeds.

The Minnesota law imposes "sweeping censorship" on "millions of Minnesotans, as well as other Americans," who cannot currently use the Grok AI tool to express themselves or view the resulting works, the libertarian law firm said. 

"AI platforms can – and probably will – simply cut off access to uploads from Minnesota IP addresses" if the law remains in effect, eliminating "G-rated AI art, AI promotional images to help small businesses and nonprofits, and political activism (such as humorous, if biting, satire of public figures)," the brief says.

Just the News Spotlight

Support Just the News